»

Fan Film Review: Star Trek Continues Episode 1, “Pilgrim of Eternity”

Despite the furor over the reboot universe and the sci-fi landscape’s love for the later iterations of Star Trek, there’s still something about The Original Series that keeps bringing people back. And one way they come back is with fan films.

One such venture is Star Trek Continues, produced by Farragut Films and DracoGen Strategic Investments. It aims to pick up, in their words, “right where the original left off” with their first episode, “Pilgrim of Eternity”.

“Pilgrim of Eternity” opens on Captain Kirk and company investigating damaged power stations in a quiet region of space. They come across an anomaly that drains almost all of their power before they’re able to stop it, and when they do, they find themselves host to a rather unexpected passenger: Apollo, the Greek god they faced in the TOS episode “Who Mourns for Adonais?”. But now Apollo is an old man who just wants to die in peace.

The thing is, after what they went through last time with him, Captain Kirk and Mr. Scott are not at all sanguine about his request — and when Apollo uses his powers against the crew, their fears are borne out. At least, until Apollo himself suggests a radical way to convince the captain to trust him.

Todd Haberkorn, Vic Mignogna, and Kim Stringer as Spock, Kirk, and Uhura, respectively.

The cast of Star Trek Continues is led by Vic Mignogna, who may be best known for his voice work on shows like Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Naruto: Shippûden, and Bleach. He definitely has Kirk’s mannerisms down pat, and the look works for him, but his voice took a little getting used to and he occasionally forces the Shatnerian pauses that we so love to lampoon. He’s joined by Todd Haberkorn, a stage and voice actor, as Mr. Spock, and well-known Star Trek historian Larry Nemecek as Dr. McCoy. For Spock, Haberkorn did his best to get the look down, but he’s too slender and his voice a bit too tenor to really nail the role for me personally. Nemecek was a little better, but we’re all spoiled by Karl Urban at this point. Both actors did pull off the mannerisms and speaking patterns. And, finally, Chris Doohan (yes, James Doohan’s son) takes on the iconic role of Mr. Scott in perhaps the most accurate portrayal in the entire cast — probably because he looks a lot like TOS-era Scotty. He also looks like another actor, but I can’t place the lookalike. It’s going to drive me crazy until I do.

The original cast is rounded out by:

Grant Imahara as Mr. Sulu, seen here in a spacesuit.

  • Grant Imahara (Mythbusters) as Sulu — I don’t watch his show, but while his acting was pretty good (except for when he yelled “Simone!” — I can’t see Takei-of-old doing that either, though), his voice seemed incongruous.
  • Kim Stinger as Uhura — she also appeared on Star Trek Phase 2, which to my mind is the gold standard in TOS fan-films, and she brings the same strong performances to “Pilgrim of Eternity”.
  • Wyatt Lenhart as Chekov — He only had one or two lines, and he delivered them fine. I’d have to see him act more to make a better analysis of his work.

There are also quite a few big-name guest stars, including Jamie Bamber (Battlestar Galactica) as Mr. Simone, Marina Sirtis as the computer voice, and I could swear I saw Amanda Foreman (Crewman Hannity in the reboot universe) but she wasn’t credited so I could be wrong.

Michele Specht as Dr. McKennah

But the two main guests are Michele Specht as Dr. Elise McKennah* and Michael Forest as Apollo. Specht’s role pretty much existed to bring in the concept of the Ship’s Counselor, and to be a woman who was both empathetic and attracted to Kirk (even though he didn’t appear to act upon it in any way, which was a nice change from how he’s usually portrayed).

Michael Forest as Apollo

However, the return of Forest in his original role (he played Apollo in the TOS episode) really stole the show. He’s 84 now, but still has a big voice, and he’s a really big guy — and since Mignogna, as Kirk, isn’t super-tall (just as Shatner isn’t super-tall either), that allows Apollo to tower over Kirk even though he appears to be powerless. I’m sure he got a kick out of returning to the role, and he played it perhaps better than before because the writing was more nuanced in some ways than 1960s television could be.

Larry Nemecek as Dr. McCoy and Todd Haberkorn as Mr. Spock

Directed by Mignogna himself and written by Mignogna, Steve Frattarola, and Jack Treviño (Deep Space Nine), “Pilgrim of Eternity” is definitely a faithful continuation to the original series. It wasn’t too complex (as TOS wasn’t), it had science and a little action (though the action wasn’t the main plot of the story), and it focused on interpersonal interaction with the crew (as TOS often did). I will say that I don’t approve of bringing back a TOS story for the pilot episode — I’d rather see the show stand on its own feet first, before starting to pull in guest stars and sequel plots — but had TOS continued for another couple of years, I could certainly see Shatner and company in this one. I do think there was a touch of fan service with Uhura singing in the Rec Room — did she really sing that often when Nichols was playing her? — but since Apollo is the Greek god of music, I suppose I can excuse it. Also, I liked the coda, which you didn’t see a lot of in TOS, and a touch of additional makeup on Forest added an additional element that made the story better.

With the exception of the compositing of Imahara and Bamber in their spacesuits and the explosion of the anomaly, the effects (both interior and exterior) were quite good. There weren’t a ton of special-effects shots actually needed for this episode, since the sets are pretty comprehensive. I don’t know if they used the same sets as Phase 2, since that one’s shot in upstate New York and (according to IMDB) this one was shot in Kingsland, Ga., but kudos go to whoever put these sets together. Same for the costuming, which is… well, I mean, it’s not that complicated, but it’s also easy to screw up because Star Trek fans are looking for mistakes anywhere they can find them.

Chris Doohan as Mr. Scott

Overall I’d say that “Pilgrim of Eternity” is a strong entry in the continuum of fan-made continuations of TOS. Though it’ll take you some time to get used to the portrayals of Kirk, Spock, and McCoy, the rest of the show is good enough to keep you watching. I look forward to the next episode.

“Pilgrim of Eternity” can be seen on Vimeo and YouTube. I prefer the latter because it has captions.

#

Note to Parents: This show contains some non-sexual mature themes, but no nudity, violence, or adult language. Captain Kirk and Apollo appear shirtless once apiece in the presentation. This should be safe for any child who can watch actual TOS episodes. Of course, you should use your own best judgment when it comes to your children.

#

* Funny story: when I was working at the University of Central Florida, my office manager’s name was Elise McKenna. She too had red hair. Coincidence? Probably.

#

About the Author

Josh Roseman (not the trombonist; the other one) lives in Georgia. His fiction has appeared in Asimov’s, Escape Pod, and the Crossed Genres anthology Fat Girl in a Strange Land. His voice has been heard around the fiction podosphere as well, including here on Escape Pod. Find him online at roseplusman.com, or on Twitter @listener42.

Comments (13)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Royal Weaver says:

    The ship sets are located in Kingsland, GA and were built by Farragut Films volunteers. Thank you for the compliment on the sets, we tried to get it just like TOS.

    • Josh Roseman says:

      I never realized the sets were in GA until I saw the notes on IMDB that this was filmed there. I only live about three hours away; I’m thinking that someday soon I might ask the producers if maybe they can help me with my father’s birthday present next year. And, y’know, it would be pretty awesome to sit in Captain Kirk’s chair.

    • Greg says:

      I think your sets are slightly better than Phase II’s sets, which in and of themselves are VERY good.

  2. Moby's! says:

    This series is a partner of Starship Farragut, and so uses the same sets as that series, in GA.

  3. On the whole I agreed with your review, The voices takle a bit of getting used to. But I liked the writing and acting and this FELT like an old Trek episode. I will have to disagree with your ‘Phase II is the gold standard’ line. Don’t get me wrong – I really like Phase II and completely support them. HOWEVER, Starship Exeter actually started befiore Phase II did and their second episode (sadly missing the last part) is far and above the other fan films. It truly feels like an extension of the old series. Phase II also has a certain actor on it (I won’t say names) that is truly awful and they keep him/her on the show becasue of the work he/she does for them. But every time he/she appears on the screen, it just takes me completely out of the episode. The best Spockl they had was replaced (Ben Tolpin). I’m not giving up on Phase II, but until that certain actor is replaced, it will always go a bit down for me (sorry if that’s too harsh). On the whole, I’ve got high hopes for STC – and ALL of the other fan films had an awful first episode, so this is a good sign. Just my 2 cents.

    • Josh Roseman says:

      I haven’t seen Exeter. I keep meaning to watch it, though. I do think that Tolpin was an excellent Spock.

      And I’ve seen the “certain actor” thing on other fan film series (serieses) before — I love Hidden Frontier, but there’s one actor on there that makes me cringe every time s/he is on the screen.

    • Greg says:

      I’m afraid I have to disagree slightly with the OP’s choice of “best Spock” for Phase II. Jeff Quinn was a LOT better than Tolpin. And I miss Andy Bray as Checkov. Continues might try getting him for their use since he doesn’t work with P2 anymore.

  4. Jeffrey R. Plum says:

    Apollo’s hair is full at the beginning of the episode, but disappears when he sings in the Rec Room. The toupee is there throughout much of the episode, but gone at times. Otherwise, the episode is very strong!

    • Josh Roseman says:

      I actually thought that was intentional — the stronger Apollo was, the “better” his hair was. If you notice, after he heals Uhura, his hair is thicker.

  5. Ted Thompson says:

    Just so you know, the uniforms were from ANOVOS, so I’d expect them to be accurate.

  6. Mike Kalka says:

    I have to say, this is the finest ‘fan’ film I’ve seen yet. It’s so true to the original series. The sets are beautiful, the cast pretty darned good, the lighting, pacing, editing, and story are all quite polished. Bravo, bravo, bravo.

  7. Larry says:

    I thought this was very good. Defiantly the best fan project to date. I got a little teary eyed at the end as it really brought back the feeling of TOS. I hope that there will be a new series continuing the classic canon. I thought both Star trek ‘reboot’ had nothing that made Star Trek great. “I was never a Star Trek fan.” – J.J. Abrams